Policy Committee Meeting 9_28_2023

Appendix C: Peer Review Expectations/Checklist Document/Manuscript Title: Corresponding Author: Assigned Reviewer: Y/N

Suggestions to writing group

Does the TITLE accurately and concisely reflect the content of the manuscript? Does the TITLE accurately and concisely reflect the content of the manuscript? Are the objectives of the investigation clearly stated in the INTRODUCTION? Is proper terminology consistent with ICS/IUGA consensus papers utilized in the manuscript? Is the MATERIALS and METHODS section adequately detailed to allow reproduction of the study? Is patient follow-up adequately detailed? Are TABLES/FIGURES appropriately labeled and referenced in the manuscript? Have the results been appropriately interpreted in the DISCUSSION? Are the CONCLUSIONS supported by the data presented? Are the implications of the study implicitly stated? Have the authors stated the limitations of their study? Have the authors explained how this study contributes to the already published literature? Have you alerted the authors of any grammar, spelling, or structural errors in the manuscript?